From a gain in legal protection to a gap in legal protection

Publication: Protection gap


Intercantonal double taxation between a substantive promise of protection and procedural erosion: a critical review of the case law 2023–2026


Archiv für Schweizerisches Abgaberecht (ASA), vol. 95, issue 3 (2026/2027), pp. 65–116
Patrizia Stiegler and Martin Jau
Language: German (abstract also in French)


The prohibition of intercantonal double taxation is a constitutional right. The federal act that was meant to govern its application has been outstanding since 1874. The article reviews the case law of the Federal Supreme Court from 2023 to 2026 and reveals a contradiction: in substance the court has strengthened protection, in procedure it has narrowed it at three points.


For a definable group of cases the right can therefore no longer be enforced. The authors derive from the case law that the cantons are already obliged under current law to eliminate existing double taxation. They also propose an amendment to the Tax Harmonisation Act. A practical checklist and a register of the decisions discussed conclude the article.


Topics covered

  • The legislative mandate against double taxation, unfulfilled since 1874
  • Change of practice by the Federal Supreme Court since BGE 149 II 354
  • Split nullity, closed revision (BGE 151 II 673), strict requirements for the relief sought
  • Duty of the cantons to eliminate double taxation, proposed Art. 51 para. 1 lit. d StHG, practical checklist


Article at ASA online (Weblaw, in German)