Methodological reflections on indirect partial liquidation

Archiv für Schweizerisches Abgaberecht (ASA), Vol. 74, No. 3, 2005, pp. 125 et seq.
Martin Jau, with Michael Buchser
Language: German
The starting point is a judgment of the Federal Supreme Court in a classic heirs' holding company case: a sole shareholder sold his company to a holding company owned by his children, which financed the purchase price from the profits of the subsidiary. The Federal Supreme Court assumed an indirect partial liquidation and taxed the sale proceeds as investment income.
The authors examine whether this result can be supported methodologically by statutory interpretation or by filling a gap in the law. They conclude that the law provides no basis for such far-reaching intervention. Taxation could at most be justified in cases of obviously abusive arrangements.
Topics covered
- Facts and reasoning of the Federal Supreme Court
- Distinguishing tax-free capital gains from investment income
- Interpretation, gap-filling and tax avoidance